I'm a relatively new listener to the Challenge, and I'd never heard of any of these podcasts before...
Left-Handed Radio seems like a really tight, well-constructed sketch show. I don't have a huge appetite for sketch, but I'm happy to say I could see myself tuning into this on a somewhat regular basis.
Dum Dum Club was my other top pick this week, and they've been one of my favorites each week so far. They have a great chemistry and they seem to be on the same page in terms of where to take the story or the riff. I really enjoyed last week's sketch, so I could picture really loving this podcast if they extended beyond simply riffing each week.
Totally Laime seems OK. This week didn't seem especially strong to me, but I can get into what they do most of the time.
Bob & Dan don't really have a hook for me, but I enjoyed this week's ep a little more than previous ones.
F Plus just doesn't appeal to me. Not only does it just seem like "gross-out humor" plus "let's all laugh at the freaks," the hosts don't even really bring anything to it. I might find some enjoyment in it if they used random internet stuff as a springboard to an original conversation or to talk to their guests.
Matt, Kulap and Jordan did a great job assessing each show - looking forward to tomorrow's episode!