LahiruDayananda

Get's a YES vote from me. A classic film.

Agree with Devin that this is a shoddily made film, but there's something about it that elevates it and makes it truly resonant. I'm going with Amy, it should be in.

Yes, hands down... I hear ya Devin! Amy's critiques seemed to be fixated on trivialities (incorrectly to boot!). This is a great film and really one of the very few serial killer films that is worth watching.

I've got to go with Superman on this one. I love both of these films despite their flaws. The second half of Superman does stumble but I think still holds together, and overall the goodwill earned by the absolutely sublime first half makes the whole package a classic. It's the best Superman film featuring the best incarnation of Superman. Batman just never quite reaches those same heights. It's very good, but not a near masterpiece.