I am a very soft no. I am both a huge Billy Wilder and Ray Milland fan and as others have noted, I believe I have voted for "lesser" films in the past but I have to draw the line here. There are better Wilder( a Sunset Blvd episode might be unanimous), Milland( I'd love to see "Ministry of Fear" in the Canon) and better addiction pictures. There are also films which pushed the code further and in more interesting ways.
When I first heard that this movie would be the subject of an episode I thought it would be an easy yes. After a rewatch, a listen to the episode and some soul searching I came to a very surprising conclusion. This very conflicted decision will probably make me much more critical in the future about these votes, which is a good thing.
