Pennies from Heaven vs. Synecdoche, New York

[HoldenMartinson 221]

This may actually be even more cruel, but this way, at least ONE of them gets in--assuming there wouldn't be a ton of "neither" votes.

 

That said, I think this could be a fun episode about dissecting how we can have favorites that are so different from one another, despite having the same weight. This wouldn't necessarily make either film canon-worthy, but it would make for a neat discussion.

[Threshold 93]

I'm all for this, especially considering Pennies from Heaven is depressing and bad, while Synecdoche, New York is depressing and great.

[JonHillman 40]

I think Synecdoche, New York actually has a really good shot at getting in on its own, but I'd be down for this idea.

[gene_shallot 79]

Ha love the idea. No pressure on Amy - either way, a fave gets in! Unless everyone abstained. But... why would someone do that.