If The Adventures of Robin Hood gets in with anything less than a unanimous (or near-unanimous) vote—or, worse yet, doesn't get in at all—I will be very disappointed with The Canon's audience. This is absolutely one of my all-time favorite films, and even though I saw it when I was still a kid, I was in high school, just the right age to be stupidly cynical and dismissive of something this old-fashioned and fun. (Admittedly, this is when I was getting into a phase of trying to catch up on historically important movies—especially anything people suggested had been an influence on Star Wars—because I was still young and hopeful enough to believe I would one day become a film director.) I just can't say enough what a thoroughly wonderful viewing experience it is. There is nothing about The Adventures of Robin Hood that doesn't work.
Aside from that, the story of a nobleman who shuns other nobles—and, to an extent, his own nobility—in the interest of doing what is right for the common people is something that's always spoken to my bleeding liberal heart. I can only imagine how this resonated with a country just beginning to emerge from its long, hard climb out of the Great Depression.