I'm definately a pseudo-fan of this band. I've never seen them live, but for some random reason, I really got into their album Undermind. I know that studio Phish is not highly regarded, but I think this album has some really great straightforward guitar rock. Any power pop fan would love a song like The Connection and there are some pretty excellent psychedelic-type songs (A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing) and even some more orchestrated (as in, played with an orchestra) songs like Secret Smile. To my ears, this album makes a great case for Phish outside of any "jam band" context.
Also, did Scott ever post his top ten bands? I'm curious about these, if posting them does not constitute some egregious invasion of privacy. Please share...and please make another episode! I'd listen to Scott and Harris talk about almost anything.