I like phish, but am not a typical fan. I hate them live. If lovin' phish studio albums is wrong, I don't wanna be right If you want Scott to hate them forever, keep playing live stuff. If you want him to actually like them, keep to the studio stuff. Don't look at it from a fanboy perspective, you did a good job last week. Keep it up! But stick to studio, don't play him the jams or you will lose him forever. I would rather drag my balls through broken glass than listen to live phish. Feed him hoist or nectar. Cannot go wrong with those!!!