Don't Go in the Woods has a 17% on Rottentomatoes.com; that's how you know I'm not just nominating it because an obnoxious girl I went to high school with is in it and won't shut up about it on Facebook.
(Additional recommendations: Lady in the Water, which I think was made for HDTGM, and my personal favorite, Across the Universe. I know there's less of a unanimous opinion on that one, but maybe your keenly trained eyes can see it for the ridiculous pile of garbage that it is.)