One of my absolute favorite running bits in the show -- which we actually haven't seen that much in a while -- is Scott's rigid insistence on continuity and internal logic in the bits. His insistence on doing the math on horse births and horse funerals in this one was unbelievable.
That was a great WYR. Loved "this is more of a statement than a question" (unprecedented?), loved the contestants' insistence that animals can't be mean and Scott's draconian adherence to the scenario as given. What a pro.
How is "Superman's Pal, Werner Herzog" not a thing yet? I would absolutely read that.
I created an account for the sole purpose of seconding this, the best idea in the history of the human race.