Hey Matt. I think you should let your guests join in on the Case Closed segment, providing they come in with an open mind. For last weeks, I'm willing to bet Mike Still would have put the caller's jumbled words into perspective, rather than instinctively teaming up with you on the guy. He seems like a guy with his own opinion.
It's good when there's more than 2 sides to an argument, especially one that isnt that emotionally invested.
Plus it would probably lead to some incredible improv.
Love the podcast.